DTF vs. White Toner Transfer

Are you looking for a solution on how to profitably and efficiently handle custom garment decoration orders? In your quest for the answer, you may have encountered direct-to-film (DTF) using inkjet printers or white toner transfer (WTT) using xerographic laser printers.

Similarities

Let's start by looking at the similarities between these technologies. Both involve printing on a film—a PET based transparent material with a special coating suitable for the specific process. The white coloring is used in both to provide an underlying base for the CMY or CMYK colors. Both use an "after print" adhesive additive—the "marry sheet" for WTT or the "powder" for DTF—which provides the bonding agent for durability on the substrate. Both heat transfer applications support a wide range of cold peel-based substrate types and result in bright colors with fine detail and good durability.

Differences

Now let's break down the differences. One of the most important differences is the technical support. DTF printing might as well be called DIY-DTF. But individual users who want to DIY need to pay attention to whether there is technical support when purchasing. Because of its newness in the market, everything about it is in the early stages of establishment, with only a few brands and dealers able to offer warranties and ongoing supply. On the other hand, WTT is supported on many levels, starting with the laser printer manufacturers providing warrantied printers to dealer partners who offer parts, support, and training.

White toner transfer printing	Direct-to-film printing

The next difference is the process. After managing to get a suitable inkjet printer for DTF and filling it with DTF inks, you need to find a RIP to run it. While a few new RIPs are coming on the market for these devices, most of the current sources for modified printers use questionable or hacked RIP software that you will have to figure out on your own. It's better to buy the DTF machine from a professional company. WTT has five to seven years of RIP development behind it that drives a dry powder toner printer.

The unique textile inks used in DTF have improved from traditional direct-to-garment (DTG) inks by using a smaller pigment size. Both DTG and DTF inks suffer from pigment settling, an issue that requires both vigorous agitation and frequent heavy cleaning cycles. However, while the larger pigments in DTG cause inkjet head clogging, this is a bit less of a problem with the DTF inks.

DTF deposits a liquid ink layer on the DTF transfer film using a DTF inkjet printer. After printing, and while the DTF ink is still wet, comes the application of the adhesive powder by shaking it across the sheet and flicking the back of the sheet to knock off the excess powder. After the powder is applied, it needs to be melted and the ink dried. You can do these steps manually, but you need to be careful about the risk of accidentally boiling the ink. It will be more convenient to buy a machine that integrates powder shaking and drying.

Direct-to-film powder application	Direct-to-film powder melting down and ink drying

WTT uses a fast laser printer. After printing, the dry print is then "married" with an adhesive sheet in a heat press and peeled while hot to apply the adhesive layer.

Both technologies are applied using heat transfer at similar temperatures and pressure. WTT requires cold peel, while DTF has developed a hot peel technology now. The adhesive powder used in DTF combined with the textile inks does provide a nice feel and stretchy result. WTT requires the use of digital rasterization techniques to achieve a somewhat similar result.

White toner transfer print on a black T-shirt	Direct-to-film print on a black T-shirt

Looking ahead

If you are very DIY oriented and have an industrial shop, then DTF has a somewhat lower cost of entry and might be your choice. If you are looking for something with low maintenance and reliability along with support, then WTT is likely the better choice. Looking ahead, both technologies will improve. There will be softer, stretchier adhesives for WTT, and for DTF, I expect to see an expanded variety of adhesives for specialized purposes.

Subtextile Co. Ltd.
Address：699-18 Xuanwu Avenue, Nanjing City, China, 210000
Tel |Fax：+86 25 85416407 (GLOBAL)
Cell：+86 17798509616
Whatsapp：0086 17798509616
E-mail：[email protected]